|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 21-27
Disrespect and abuse during facility based childbirth: The experience of mothers in Kano, Northern Nigeria
TG Amole1, MJ Tukur2, SL Farouk2, AO Ashimi3
1 Department of Community Medicine, Bayero University Kano; Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital, Kano, Nigeria
2 Department of Community Medicine, Bayero University Kano, Kano, Nigeria
3 Federal Medical Centre, Birnin Kudu, Jigawa State, Nigeria
|Date of Web Publication||17-Apr-2019|
Dr. T G Amole
Department of Community Medicine, Bayero University Kano/Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital, Kano
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Context: An important but little understood concept that retards the goal to reduce maternal mortality and increase universal access to reproductive health is disrespect and abuse (D&A) during childbirth.
Aim: This study aims to determine the prevalence, pattern, perpetrators, and determinants of D&A during childbirth among recently parturient women in Kano, north western Nigeria.
Settings and Design: Using a cross-sectional design, 332 women accessing child immunization and postnatal services at Murtala Muhammad Specialist Hospital, Kano, were selected.
Subjects and Methods: Respondents were selected using systematic sampling technique and data collected using an adapted, interviewer administered tool.
Statistical Analysis: Data was analysed using IBM SPSS version 21.0 and level of significance set at 0.05.
Results: Respondents (n = 306) had a mean age of 27.7 ± 6.3 years and more than half (55.9%; n = 171) had experienced at least one form of D&A during childbirth. Commonest forms of abuse were abandonment and nonconfidential care (84.5%, n = 142; 67.9%, n = 114, respectively). Main perpetrators were nurses/midwives (83.0%, n = 142). The experience during the last childbirth was significantly higher among respondents of non-Hausa/Fulani ethnic group (χ2 = 6.10; P = 0.014), of the Christian faith (χ2 = 8.62; P = 0.003), and with formal education (χ2 = 19.94; P = 0.0001). After controlling for confounders, formal education remained a predictor for experiencing abuse at childbirth (AOR = 2.43; 95% confidence interval = 1.11--5.32).
Conclusions: D&A during childbirth is prevalent in our setting. Educating healthcare providers and women about their responsibilities and rights will enhance provision and utilization of quality maternal health services.
Keywords: Childbirth; disrespect and abuse; facility; mothers.
|How to cite this article:|
Amole T G, Tukur M J, Farouk S L, Ashimi A O. Disrespect and abuse during facility based childbirth: The experience of mothers in Kano, Northern Nigeria. Trop J Obstet Gynaecol 2019;36:21-7
|How to cite this URL:|
Amole T G, Tukur M J, Farouk S L, Ashimi A O. Disrespect and abuse during facility based childbirth: The experience of mothers in Kano, Northern Nigeria. Trop J Obstet Gynaecol [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Sep 17];36:21-7. Available from: http://www.tjogonline.com/text.asp?2019/36/1/21/256483
| Introduction|| |
The death of a woman during pregnancy, childbirth, or within 42 days of terminating the pregnancy or delivery remains a source of agony to the immediate family and a socioeconomic loss to community. In 2010, an estimated 287,000 maternal deaths occurred worldwide, majority of which were from developing nations and Nigeria accounted for 14%. At this estimate, Nigeria's maternal mortality ratio (MMR) was put at 630 with a range of 370--1,200/100,000 live births. According to the Nigeria Demographic Health Survey (NDHS) of 2013, the MMR was estimated to be 576/100,000 live births,, with values notably higher in the northern region compared with the south and also in the rural areas. The reasons for this high MMR are multipronged and complex; access to, and utilization of emergency obstetric care services in various parts of the country regarded as main causes. Reduction of maternal mortality has long been a global concern and priority as enunciated by the Millennium Development Goals (MDG) framework, the Global Strategy for Women's and Children's Health, and the Sustainable Development Goals.,, To further advance the reduction of maternal mortality in Nigeria, factors influencing nonutilization of maternal health services need to be addressed, since it is the patient that presents to the facility that counts.
According to the NDHS 2013 and other reports,,,, cost of healthcare services, distance of health facility, services not conforming to tradition, waiting time, and negative attitude of providers, all play significant roles in nonutilization of maternal healthcare services in Nigeria. This may explain the high rates of home delivery among pregnant women irrespective of having received prenatal care or not, especially in northern Nigeria.
What constitutes negative providers' attitude to clients varies, but certainly includes disrespect and abuse (D&A). These ultimately affect the quality of care, and may influence subsequent utilization of the services provided by the facility, consequently, negatively influencing other clients. D&A towards patients is subjective and challenging to define as it is often dependent and modified by the environment, time, birth outcomes, and personal expectations. Researchers have defined D&A during childbirth as “interactions and facility conditions that local consensus deem to be humiliating or undignified, and those interactions or conditions that are experienced as or intended to be humiliating or undignified;” and any form of inhumane treatment or uncaring behavior towards a woman during labor and delivery. Although Bowser and Hill identified seven categories of D&A: physical abuse, nonconsented care, nonconfidential care, nondignified care, discrimination based on specific patient attributes, abandonment of care, and detention in facilities, d'Oliveira worked on four types of violence: neglect; verbal violence, including rough treatment, threats, scolding, shouting, and intentional humiliation; physical violence, including denial of pain relief when technically indicated; and sexual violence. Women in labor expect empathy, support, confidentiality, and respect from their birth attendants.
D&A can constitute poor quality of care and become a powerful disincentive for women to use and seek maternal healthcare services., The documented proportion of women across the globe experiencing disrespectful, abusive, or neglectful treatment during childbirth varies: 13--28% of women attending gynecological clinics in northern Europe had experienced abuse within the healthcare system during pregnancy, delivery, or the postnatal period; a comparable 20% in Kenya; and an astronomically high 98% from a facility based study in Enugu, southeast Nigeria.
Increasing the population of women delivering in a health facility is challenging, as it requires comprehensive efforts to overcome multifaceted obstacles to accessing facility-based care as well as reforming poor quality of care at facilities., D&A during childbirth represent important barriers to utilization of skilled birth care during subsequent deliveries and constitute a common cause of suffering and human rights violations for women in many countries. The fear of experiencing D&A negatively influences women's decisions to seek care at health facility during labor and delivery.
In Nigeria, the proportion of births supervised by skilled birth attendance (36%) has remained low despite high uptake of prenatal care (60%). D&A is an important but poorly understood component of the quality of care that women receive during childbirth in our facilities. To improve quality of care given by healthcare providers as a way of driving uptake, this study sought to quantify D&A in our setting, describe the pattern, the perpetrators, as well as associated factors during childbirth in Kano, northwestern Nigeria.
| Subjects and Methods|| |
The study was conducted at the Murtala Muhammad Specialist Hospital (MMSH) in Kano, Nigeria. The hospital is located in Kano city, a place often described as the core of Kano state. There are three state owned tertiary hospitals in the state and all are in Kano city. The MMSH is one of the state government owned tertiary hospitals and is the most patronized. It is the oldest hospital in northern Nigeria having been established in 1927. It was initially called City Hospital, was renamed after the assassination of the former Nigeria Head of State, General Murtala Ramat Muhammad in 1976 and became a specialist hospital in 1987. It is located along Kofar Mata road in Kano Municipal Local Government Area. It receives referrals from all the 44 local governments in the state, neighboring states of Jigawa, Katsina, Bauchi, and Zamfara. The hospital is a 250 bedded facility and it has four main clinical departments and other nonclinical departments. The hospital provides free maternal and child care facilities especially for children under 5 years, a programme initiated by the state government 17 years ago before this study.
The department of Obstetrics and Gynecology is run by three consultants, six medical officers, three senior medical officers, and 69 nurses and midwives who run shifts. The total number of deliveries in 2016 was 9,585 with an average of 799 deliveries/month.
A cross-sectional descriptive study design was used.
Selection and description of participants
Mothers accessing services at the postnatal and immunization clinics of MMSH, who delivered at MMSH within the last 6 weeks prior to the study were included. Women delivered at home were excluded from the study.
The sample size for this study (333) was calculated using the formula: n = z2 pq/d2; where z is the standard normal deviate at 95% confidence level, “p” is prevalence of abandonment/neglect during childbirth in a previous study = 0.291, degree of precision was set at 5% and calculated sample size adjusted by 5% to compensate for nonresponse.
The average number of women attending the immunization clinic for the first and second visit (0--6 weeks) and the postnatal clinic were estimated and the average monthly attendance estimated to form a sampling frame. Subsequently, the sampling fraction and the sampling interval were calculated. The first respondent each day was chosen using simple random sampling technique (using a random number table). This was repeated on subsequent clinic day until the sample size was achieved.
Study instruments and data collection
A pretested, structured interviewer administered questionnaire was used to collect data. The questionnaire was adapted from tools used in previous studies on related topics. The tool had four sections: section A obtained information on sociodemographic characteristics (age, gender, religion, marital status, occupation, and parity) of the respondent; section B determined prevalence and pattern of D&A (questions on forms of physical and verbal abuse, failure to meet professional standards of care and poor rapport between woman and provider); section C determined the perpetrators (cadre of skilled birth attendant) of D&A; and section D assessed factors (such as the experience of complication(s) during last delivery) that may be associated with D&A in childbirth. Specific questions used in the study were pilot tested with a small random sample of potential respondents (number = 40; not included in the study) to ascertain the appropriateness of the items included. In general, there was good internal consistency among the items indicating that the instrument was reliable and valid. On each immunization and postnatal clinic day, selected participants were invited individually into a separate room and informed consent obtained using the consent form. They were assured of privacy, no revelation of identifying information, and no interference with the quality of care they will receive with nonparticipation. Only consenting participants were interviewed. The questionnaires were administered to the respondents by trained research assistants who were female medical students. Their training included obtaining informed consent and interviewing techniques.
The tool was pretested among 40 postnatal women accessing immunization services at Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital. This was to identify ambiguous questions, ensure appropriateness of questions, and skip patterns.
Data was entered and analyzed using IBM SPSS version 21. Qualitative data was summarized using frequencies and percentages, whereas quantitative data was summarized using mean and standard deviation. Chi-square test was used to determine significant associations between respondents' sociodemographic characteristics and the experience of D&A at childbirth. Statistical significance was set at P ≤5%. Using a P value of 0.1 as cut-off, variables associated with D&A were put into the logistic regression model to determine the predictors for D&A.
The study proposal was approved by the State Ministry of Health Research and Ethics Committee and informed consent was obtained from respondents. Provisions of the Helsinki declaration were respected during the study.
| Results|| |
Of the 333 questionnaires distributed, 306 were retrieved giving a response rate of 91.9%. The age of the respondents ranged from 16 to 45 years with a mean of 27.7 ± 6.3 years. Majority (91.2%) were married, of the Hausa/Fulani ethnic group (84.6%), Muslims (90.8), and (45.1%) were housewives. The sociodemographic characteristics of the respondents are shown in [Table 1].
Prevalence of disrespect and abuse during childbirth
More than half 55.9% (n = 171) of the respondents had experienced at least one form of abuse, whereas 44.1% (n = 135) did not experience any form of abuse during the last childbirth.
Pattern of disrespect and abuse
The commonest types of D&A were abandonment/neglect of care (n = 142; 84.5%), nonconfidential care (n = 114; 67.9%), and nondignified care (n = 87; 51.8%). [Table 2]. The least common was request for bribe (n = 12; 7.1%). Some respondents reported experiencing multiple forms of D&A.
Perpetrators of D&A during childbirth
The nurses/midwives were responsible for majority (n = 142; 83.0%) of the reported D & As during childbirth. Attending doctors (n = 20; 11.7%) and hospital attendants (n = 14; 8.2%) were responsible in some cases. A few reported experiencing D&A from multiple perpetrators.
Factors associated with D&A during childbirth
At bivariate level, respondents who were of non-Hausa/Fulani ethnic group, of the Christian faith, and with formal education experienced D&A more than others [Table 3]. Factors that had P value of ≤ 0.1 were subjected to logistic regression analysis and formal education remained a predictor for experiencing D&A during childbirth.
| Discussion|| |
Encouraging respectful care during childbirth is crucial to improve quality of care and utilization of skilled birth services D&A adversely impacts the utilization of health services for skilled delivery, an intervention that has been noted globally to greatly reduce maternal mortality.,, Although the introduction of free maternal health services in Kano State resulted in increased utilization of ANC and delivery services, major impacts in maternal health indices are yet to be observed and have been explained by the social factors peculiar to women in our environment. In this study, D&A during the last childbirth was common as one in every two women (55.9%) experienced it.
In many African settings, parturients are often ignored in labor until they shout “head is coming down” or the birth attendant can sight the head of the baby. This may explain abandonment/neglect of care as the commonest form of D&A reported in this study. When this is done intentionally, it may be because of negligence, provider temperament, and superiority complex, or unintentional when the health worker is overworked, busy with other tasks, or attending to other patients. Inadequacy of health workers have also contributed to D&A during childbirth., A global systematic review, landscape analysis by Bowser and Hill, and other studies conducted in Nigeria and Kenya, also reported the commonest form as abandonment/neglect of care. Analgesia is not commonly given to parturients in this environment; as such many women mentioned that they were ignored when they sought pain relief and left unattended to. D&A may adversely impact the utilisation of health services for delivery, an intervention that has been noted globally to reduce maternal mortality. Despite the fewer number of midwives in the lab our ward compared with the number of parturients in labor at any point in time, there are few options to pain relief accessible to the midwives.
Other poor quality services such as being uncovered during delivery or examination and medical history disclosure without consent violates the privacy of women during childbirth and may discourage them from delivering in health facilities. Although this study did not ascertain the HIV status of the patients studied, a similar study in Kenya among HIV-positive women reiterated that issues related to trust in the treatment offered at health facilities could affect demand and utilization of services. The lack of trust in the confidentiality of treatment at health facilities was so great that the women chose to deliver at home, where their HIV status would not be disclosed to other community members or health workers.
The perpetrators of D&A included doctors, nurses/midwives, and attendants. Although the provision of free maternal health services in the health facility led to increased utilization, the resultant increase in workload precipitated decreased staff morale and poor quality of services., The midwives who are often the foremost skilled attendant at most deliveries were reported by the majority as the perpetrators (83.0%), similar to what was found globally in a mixed systematic review, and also in studies conducted in Ghana, Kenya, and Nigeria., Healthcare providers may perpetrate disrespectful and abusive care as a result of their perception and beliefs. Also providers may want to “train and discipline” the women rather than treat them. Healthcare providers may also feel that they are entitled to use a range of strategies, including physical violence to achieve control and punish perceived disobedience. Such negative behavior may stem from the social norms which influence both practice and expectations of power, often implying that care providers are in control of women. Moreover, lack of repercussions for unacceptable health worker behavior can fuel a sense of entitlement.
Respondents who were of the Christian faith, of non-Hausa/Fulani ethnicity, and better educated were more likely to report being abused than those of Islamic faith, Hausa/Fulani ethnicity, and those with informal education. Women of minority tribes are more likely to report abusive care because they speak different languages, with different cultural norms and practices from those of the majority and the caregivers as well. Also, in the Hausa/Fulani communities who constituted the majority in this setting, the culture and tradition discourages women from shouting, crying, or showing much distress during labor. Better educated women probably have higher expectations of quality of care. Findings in Tanzania and India noted that D&A was higher among women who were better educated, had higher expectations of quality of care, and with greater empowerment to report abuse. Lack of awareness on respectful maternity care among respondents with lower level of education may contribute to their inability to differentiate between acceptable standard of care, and what is regarded as abnormal or unethical. Women may underreport abuse because of normalization of the poor quality care., Other social factors such as marital status were noted to affect D&A as unmarried women were more likely to be abused than those married. This is probably because of lack of support from partner or family members and financial instability.
Education of service providers and women as regards their responsibilities and rights while providing or receiving care is of utmost importance in the prevention of D&A. Clear delineations of what a provider is expected to give while providing care, and what quality of health service a woman should expect would need to be displayed at all health facilities and in the most understood language. To understand and quantify D&A in Nigeria, the government and health development partners would need to promote and support further research into defining D&A. With this, interventions that holistically address policy makers, healthcare workers' training, and service delivery as well as individuals and communities can be planned and implemented.
This study may be limited as it used only quantitative methods to assess women in a health facility immunization and postnatal clinics, whereas a significant proportion of women in this environment deliver at home and do not access postnatal care. Subsequent research will need to employ qualitative research methods to explore the interplay between choice of place of delivery, the birth attendant, and D&A at childbirth. Although some of the responses may be due to social desirability bias, pertinent information was gathered from this study.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, WORLD BANK. Trend in Maternal Mortality 1990 – 2010. Geneva, Switzerland. Available from: www.who.int/gho/maternal_health/countries/en/index.html. [Last accessed on 2017 Oct 05].
Ransom EI, Yinger NV. Making Motherhood safer: Overcoming obstacles on the pathway to care. Available from: www.prb.org/pdf/makmotherhdsafer_Eng.pdf. [Last accessed on 2017 Nov 10].
National Population Commission (NPC) [Nigeria] and ICF Macro. Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey 2013. Abuja, Nigeria: National Population Commission and ICF Macro; 2014. p. 273-8.
National Population Commission (NPC) [Nigeria] and ICF Macro. Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey 2008. Abuja, Nigeria: National Population Commission and ICF Macro; 2009. p. 125-41.
United Nations' Secretary General. Global Strategy for Women's and Children's Health. New York: United Nations; 2010.
Adekunle AS, Oloyede AO, Okanlawon IO. Factors influencing non utilisation of maternity care services in Sagamu. Trop J Obstet Gynecol 2006;23:48-53.
Idris SH, Sambo MN, Ibrahim MS. Barriers to utilisation of maternal health services in a semi urban community in northern Nigeria: The clients' perspective. Niger Med J 2013;54:27-32.
] [Full text]
Ashimi AO, Amole TG. Prevalence, reasons and predictors for homebirths among pregnant women attending antenatal care in Birnin Kudu North West Nigeria. Sexual Reprod Healthc 2015;6:119-25.
Rosen HE, Lynam PF, Carr C, Reis V, Ricca J, Bazant ES, et al.
Direct observation of respectful maternity care in five countries: A cross-sectional study of health facilities in East and Southern Africa. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2015;15:306.
Bohren MA, Vogel PJ, Hunter EC, Lutsiv O, Makh SK, Souza JP, et al.
The mistreatment of women during childbirth in health facilities globally: A mixed-methods systematic review. PLoS Med 2015;12:e1001847.
The Population Council Kenya. Confronting Disrespect and Abuse During Childbirth in Kenya. The Heshima project. Nairobi: The population council (Kenya) 2014. 2p.
d'Oliveira AFPL, Diniz SG, Schraiber LB. Violence against women in health-care institutions: An emerging problem. Lancet 2002;359:1681-5.
Okafor II, Ugwu EO, Obi SN. Disrespect and abuse during facility based childbirth in a low –income country. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2014;128:110-3.
World Health Organization. The prevention and elimination of disrespect and abuse during facility based childbirth. Department of Reproductive health and research. WHO; 2014. 4p. Report no WHO/Rhr/14.23.
Miller S, Lalonde A. The global epidemic of abuse and disrespect during childbirth: History, evidence, interventions, and FIGO's mother-baby friendly birthing facilities initiative. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2015;131(Suppl 1):S49-52.
Schroll A, Kjaergaard H, Midtgaard J. Encountering abuse in healthcare; lifetime experiences in postnatal women – A qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2013;13:74.
Abuya T, Waren CE, Miller N, Njuki R, Ndwiga C, Maranga A, et al.
Exploring the prevalence of disrespect and abuse during childbirth in Kenya. PLoS One 2015;10:e0123606. doi: 10.1371/journal. Pone. 0123606.
Galadanci HS, Idris SA, Sadauki HM, Yakasai IA. Programs and policies for reducing maternal mortality in Kano State, Nigeria: A Review. Afr J Reprod Health 2010;14:31-6.
Vo Isola F, Owolabi O, Fjillippi V. Disrespect and abuse of women during childbirth in Nigeria: A systematic review. PLoS One 2017;12:e0174084. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone. 0174084.
Balde MD, Diallo BA, Bangoura A, Sall O, Soumah AM, Vogel JP, et al.
Perceptions and experiences of the mistreatment of women during childbirth in health facilities In Guinea : A qualitative study with women and service providers. Reprod Health 2017;14:1-13.
Vogel JP, Bohren MA, Tunçalp O, Oladapo OT, Gülmezoglu AM. Promoting respect and preventing mistreatment during childbirth. BJOG 2016;123:671-4.
Crissman H, Crespo K, Nimako D, Domena J, Engmann C, Adanu R, et al.
Intention to deliver in a health care facility and health care facility based delivery rates among women in Akwatia, Ghana. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2011;1132:161-2.
Essendi H, Mills S, Fotso J. Barriers to formal emergency obstetric care services utilization. J Urban Health 2010;88:356-69.
Bohren MA, Vogel JP, Tunçalp Ö, Fawole B, Titiloye MA, Olanrewaju A, et al.
“By slapping their laps, the patient will know that you truly care for her” : A qualitative study on social norms and acceptability of the mistreatment of women during childbirth in Abuja, Nigeria. SSM Popul Health 2016;2:640-55.
Okafor C, Rizzuto R. Womens and health care providers views of maternal practices services in rural Nigeria. Studies Fam Plann 1994;25:353-61.
Jewkes R, Penn-Kekana L. Mistreatment of women in childbirth: Time for action on this important dimension of violence against women. PLoS Med 2015;12:6-9.
Sudhinaraset M, Treleaven E, Melo J, Singh K, Diamond-smith N. Women's status and experiences of mistreatment during childbirth in Uttar Pradesh: A mixed methods study using cultural health capital theory. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2016;16:1-12.
Kruk ME, Kujawski S, Mbaruku G, Ramsey K, Moyo W, Freedman LP. Disrespectful and abusive treatment during facility delivery in Tanzania: A facility and community survey. Health Policy Plan 2018;33:e26-33.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]